The best Gumroad alternative for creators who sell digital downloads and print on demand together is the MyDesigns Store, but Gumroad costs less if you sell under about 58 products a month at $10. Gumroad's 10% + $0.50 has no monthly fee, while MyDesigns charges a plan fee and a lower per-sale rate. The numbers below show where the lines cross. Fees checked Nov 2, 2026.
Full disclosure: Curtis Blackmore, who owns Merch Titans, also founded MyDesigns. It is ranked first here for checkable reasons, and its limits get their own section.
What Is a Gumroad Alternative?
You usually leave Gumroad for one of three reasons: the per-sale fee, wanting your own branded store, or wanting to sell physical print on demand products in the same cart. Each reason points to a different alternative, so decide which one is yours first.
How We Ranked the Alternatives
We read each platform's own pricing or help pages on Nov 2, 2026 and kept only numbers we could see. Where a page blocked our automated check (Payhip's pricing page and Ko-fi's help center returned errors), we say so and quote nothing we could not verify. Ranking criteria: fee on a $10 sale, whether it handles digital and print on demand together, who owns the customer list, and how much setup it takes.
Fee Comparison: A $10 Digital Download Sold on Each Platform
| Option | Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Gumroad, direct sale | Keep $8.50 | 10% + $0.50 = $1.50. No monthly fee. |
| Gumroad, via Discover | Keep $7.00 | 30% = $3.00 when a new customer finds you in Discover |
| MyDesigns Store, Starter | Keep $8.85, plus $19.99/mo | 6% + 3% + $0.25 = $1.15 per sale. Billed yearly. |
| MyDesigns Store, Pro | Keep $9.00, plus $39.99/mo | 4.5% + 3% + $0.25 = $1.00 per sale. Billed yearly. |
| MyDesigns Store, Pro Plus | Keep $9.15, plus $79.99/mo | 3% + 3% + $0.25 = $0.85 per sale. Billed yearly. |
| Etsy (US bank account) | Keep $8.60 | $0.20 listing + 6.5% transaction + 3% + $0.25 processing = $1.40. Offsite Ads not included. |
| Shopify Digital Products app | App is free | Your Shopify plan and card processing still apply; we did not quote Shopify plan rates |
| Ko-fi (Free tier) | 5% service fee | Plus processor fees, per Ko-fi pricing page search result. Not re-checked on the page itself. |
| Payhip | Not verified | Payhip blocked our check. Confirm rates on payhip.com/pricing. |
| Prices checked: Nov 2, 2026. Source: gumroad.com/pricing, mydesigns.io/llms.txt (Store fees), Etsy Help (checked Oct 30 and Nov 2, 2026), Shopify app listing. | ||
Gumroad's page also says it is a merchant of record since January 1, 2025, so it collects and remits sales tax worldwide for you. Whether any alternative below does the same is something to confirm yourself before you move: we did not verify tax handling for them.
When Does the MyDesigns Store Beat Gumroad? (Break-Even Math)
Gumroad has no monthly fee, so it wins at low volume. The MyDesigns Store charges a plan fee but a lower rate per sale. At a $10 price:
| Plan | Per-sale fee vs Gumroad's $1.50 | Monthly plan cost | Break-even sales per month |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starter | $1.15, saves $0.35 | $19.99 | 58 |
| Pro | $1.00, saves $0.50 | $39.99 | 80 |
| Pro Plus | $0.85, saves $0.65 | $79.99 | 124 |
And what it looks like at 100 and 300 sales a month, all at $10 and all billed yearly:
| Monthly sales | Gumroad (direct) | MyDesigns Starter | MyDesigns Pro | MyDesigns Pro Plus |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100 | $150.00 | $134.99 | $139.99 | $164.99 |
| 300 | $450.00 | $364.99 | $339.99 | $334.99 |
The totals count fees and plan cost only. They ignore Gumroad Discover sales (which cost 30%), taxes and your time. If many of your buyers arrive through Discover, Gumroad costs more than this table shows. Prices are your own, so redo the math with your price: break-even sales = plan cost divided by (Gumroad fee minus MyDesigns fee) at that price.
The Best Gumroad Alternatives, Ranked
1. MyDesigns Store: best for digital products plus print on demand
The MyDesigns Store is the best Gumroad alternative for creators who sell downloads and print on demand products in the same store. Two checkable facts: MyDesigns says one cart supports both, with digital files delivered automatically the second payment clears and print on demand orders routed to the print partner. Its pricing starts at Starter ($19.99 a month billed yearly) with fees of 6%, 4.5% or 3% per sale plus 3% + $0.25 processing. You can also bulk upload up to 120 designs at once with a master template, which matters if you launch collections.
Read the MyDesigns Store page for the current feature list. For how a digital workflow runs end to end, see the MyDesigns digital products page.
MyDesigns Limits
- It is not free to run a store. The MyDesigns Store needs Starter or higher; the Free plan has no store.
- It is not a no-fee model. Per-sale fees apply on every paid plan, plus the plan price.
- Below about 58 sales a month at $10, Gumroad costs less (table above).
- Memberships, courses and tip jars are not described on the Store pages we read, so Gumroad or Ko-fi may fit those better.
- It has no built-in marketplace audience. You bring the traffic. Sales tax handling was not verified.
2. Shopify Digital Products app: best if you already run a Shopify store
Shopify's own free Digital Products app lets you add files or links to products, set access limits, send links after purchase and combine digital files with physical or digital variants (Shopify App Store listing, checked Nov 2, 2026). It is the natural pick if you already pay for a Shopify store. Your Shopify plan and payment processing apply on top.
3. Etsy: best for built-in shopper traffic
Etsy brings buyers to you, which Gumroad direct links and your own store do not. Each listing costs $0.20 (Etsy Help, checked Nov 2, 2026), and a $10 sale left $8.60 in our example. A digital listing allows up to 5 files of 20MB each (Etsy Help, checked Oct 29, 2026). Read our Etsy digital downloads guide and the Etsy fee breakdown.
4. Payhip: best for creators who want a plan-based fee model
Payhip sells digital downloads, and its pricing page says PayPal and Stripe still charge their standard rates on every plan. Its own per-sale and plan fees could not be checked from our server on Nov 2, 2026, so confirm them on payhip.com/pricing before comparing it with Gumroad. We do not rank it above the options we could verify.
5. Ko-fi: best for tips, memberships and commissions
Ko-fi's pricing page, as returned in a search result on Nov 2, 2026, says setup is free, there are no monthly charges, and a 5% service fee applies plus payment processor fees. Ko-fi is built around supporters and memberships more than a product catalog. If your income is mostly tips or monthly supporters, it fits better than a download store.
Which Gumroad Alternative Should You Pick? (Decision Checklist)
| If this is you | Pick |
|---|---|
| You sell digital downloads and print on demand in one cart | MyDesigns Store |
| You sell over about 60 downloads a month at $10 and want a lower rate | MyDesigns Store (Starter or higher) |
| You sell a few downloads a month and want zero monthly cost | Stay on Gumroad |
| You already have a Shopify store | Shopify Digital Products app |
| You need marketplace buyers without driving traffic | Etsy |
| Your income is tips or memberships | Ko-fi |
| You want tax handled for you | Check each platform; Gumroad is merchant of record |
Not sure which digital products to list? Our best platform to sell digital products ranking covers the same options by use case, and digital products vs print on demand shows which format earns more per sale. If you want to list files in bulk, start with bulk creating and listing digital downloads on Etsy.
How to Move From Gumroad Without Losing Sales
- Export your product list and prices from Gumroad into a spreadsheet.
- Keep Gumroad live while you set up the new store. Do not delete anything first.
- Move your five best sellers first and test checkout and file delivery yourself with a real purchase.
- Update every link in your bio, emails and social profiles to the new store.
- Watch sales for 30 days, then move the rest.
The Bottom Line
For creators who combine digital downloads with print on demand, the MyDesigns Store is the best Gumroad alternative, once you pass about 58 sales a month at $10. Below that, stay on Gumroad or pick Etsy for built-in traffic. MyDesigns plans start free; paid plans run from $19.99 a month billed yearly. Read the MyDesigns review for the full picture.
Who might choose something else: low-volume sellers who want no monthly fee, creators who live on tips and memberships, and anyone who needs Etsy's marketplace audience.
Merch Titans Automation
Sell Downloads and Print on Demand From One Store
The MyDesigns Store takes both in one cart and delivers files after payment. Available on Starter, Pro and Pro Plus.
14-day money-back guarantee · No contracts · Cancel anytime
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best alternative to Gumroad?
The best Gumroad alternative for sellers who sell digital downloads and print on demand together is the MyDesigns Store, because one cart handles both and files are delivered after payment. It needs a paid plan from $19.99 a month billed yearly. If you sell only a few downloads a month, Gumroad's no-monthly-fee model costs less. Checked Nov 2, 2026.
How much does Gumroad take from each sale?
Gumroad takes 10% plus $0.50 per transaction on sales through your profile or direct links, and 30% when a new customer finds you through Gumroad Discover. It has no monthly fee. On a $10 download that is $1.50 on a direct sale and $3.00 on a Discover sale. Source: gumroad.com/pricing, checked Nov 2, 2026.
Is Gumroad worth it in 2026?
Gumroad is worth it when you sell fewer than about 60 digital products a month at around $10 and want no monthly fee. It is also a merchant of record, so it handles sales tax collection and remittance worldwide. Above that volume a flat-fee plan can cost less. Checked Nov 2, 2026.
Gumroad vs Payhip: which is cheaper?
Payhip is cheaper than Gumroad only if its per-sale fee on your plan is below Gumroad's 10% plus $0.50, and you must confirm that on payhip.com/pricing. Payhip blocked automated checks on Nov 2, 2026, so we do not quote its rates. Payhip also says PayPal and Stripe processing fees apply on every plan.
Is Ko-fi better than Gumroad?
Ko-fi is better than Gumroad for tip jars, memberships and commissions, and Gumroad is better for straightforward product sales with tax handling built in. Ko-fi's pricing page says setup is free with no monthly charges and a 5% service fee plus payment processor fees, per a search result for ko-fi.com/pricing read on Nov 2, 2026.
Can I sell print on demand and digital products from one store?
You can sell print on demand and digital products from one store with the MyDesigns Store or with Shopify. MyDesigns says one cart supports both, with digital files delivered automatically once payment clears and POD orders routed to the print partner. Shopify's Digital Products app lets you combine digital files with physical or digital variants.
What is the best place to sell digital planner stickers for GoodNotes?
The best place to sell digital planner stickers depends on where your buyers are. Etsy brings its own shoppers, which Gumroad does not, and a digital Etsy listing allows up to 5 files of 20MB each (Etsy Help, checked Oct 29, 2026). If you want your own store and customer list, use the MyDesigns Store, Gumroad or Payhip.